Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

A sheltered wood front door, tall sidelight and gray limestone pier beside an autumn oakleaf hydrangea and concrete entry walk.

Worthington Already Pays for Your Curbside Compost. Signing Up Is What Makes It Cheap.

November 5, 2026

Starting January 1, 2027, Worthington will pay The Compost Exchange $3.28 a month for every residential unit in the city. That covers all 5,252 of them, whether a household puts out a food-waste bucket or not. At that rate the City spends about $207,000 a year, or $1,035,000 over the five-year contract.

So the total is fixed. The cost per household that actually uses the service is not. Every address that registers spreads the same bill across one more kitchen. The program's price depends on how many neighbors take part, and that is the most useful thing to know before the buckets show up.

The bill is set at 5,252 homes

The City's bid documents spelled this out. Worthington asked for "a uniform and consistent per Residential Unit per month charge for curbside collection regardless of the number of participants in the program." It told bidders their price "must account for full participation, whatever that level ends up being." The same documents say that if a specialty company won the work, which happened, the City would be billed the bid price times 5,252 units.

Those documents also gave a target. The City expects about 30% participation at launch and hopes to reach at least 50% by year three. If you divide the fixed monthly bill by the households using the service at each level, you get this:

Share of homes registered Households, approx. Effective monthly cost per participating home
30%, the City's launch estimate 1,576 about $10.93
50%, the year-three goal 2,626 about $6.56
75% 3,939 about $4.37
100% 5,252 $3.28

These figures come straight from the contract math: $3.28 times 5,252 homes is about $17,227 a month, divided by the number of participating homes. No household gets a separate charge for food waste under this option. The City pays The Compost Exchange directly. That matches how Worthington already handles trash, recycling and yard waste, which the City pays for without charging residents.

Why the flat rate beat the subscription

Worthington had another way to do this. The bid package included a second option where households would subscribe and pay the hauler themselves. The lowest bids for that version came from The Compost Exchange and Local Waste Services, both at $15.00 a month. City staff didn't recommend that option, noting that curbside food-waste pickup is already sold privately in Worthington and "some subscribers pay less than $15.00 per month for those services."

The private market had already shown its limit. As of January 2026, about 4% of Worthington households paid for a curbside food-waste subscription, according to the June 8 City Council minutes. At that same meeting, Director of Service and Engineering John Moorehead told Council that the Solid Waste Authority of Central Ohio favored a City-funded model, because removing individual fees and sign-up barriers would likely bring in more participants.

Put the numbers side by side. Even at the City's cautious 30% launch estimate, the effective cost per participating home comes in under the $15 subscription bid. If participation reaches the year-three goal, the gap gets wider. The same structure that makes the program look expensive on a budget line also makes it cheaper for each user as more people join.

A 4–3 vote, and a memo that said no

None of this passed easily. In an October 14 memo, Moorehead and City Manager Robyn Stewart advised Council to vote the ordinance down, as Pique reported in its coverage of the contract. Their memo read:

"Staff recommends defeat of the Ordinance. As presented at the October 12 City Council meeting, Worthington's proposed 2027 Operating Budget does not include funding for a curbside food waste collection program."

The memo warned that paying for the program without offsetting cuts would draw down the General Fund balance. It called that "not sustainable for the longer term without additional revenue and/or expenditure cuts elsewhere." Staff listed possible offsets:

  • Keep the social services coordinator position part-time, which saves about $95,000 compared with a full-time budget
  • Use some of the $500,000 in one-time housing money in the 2026 budget that hasn't yet been assigned to specific initiatives
  • Reduce the General Fund transfer to the capital improvements program. Staff cautioned that the Selby Shelter House needs furnace and flooring work that can't wait five years

Some outside money and one savings help. SWACO is offering up to $100,000 to help launch the service, on the condition that the City runs curbside food-waste collection for at least five years. The City also currently spends $12,000 a year on a food-waste drop-off at its Recycling Convenience Center. That cost goes away because the new contract covers drop-off service too.

Council approved Ordinance No. 30-2026 on October 19 by a 4–3 vote, according to the City's meeting record. The ordinance took effect November 11, and the contract runs from January 1, 2027, through December 31, 2031. The Columbus Dispatch described the outcome as a narrow approval made "despite concerns from city staffers about how the program will be funded."

A cost that's already committed, plus a launch estimate of 30%, means registrations now decide whether that $207,000 a year buys a lot of diverted food waste or very little.

What arrives before January

The bid specification sets the order of events:

  1. Registration. Before service begins, the City sets up a registration process for interested residents and sends the registered addresses to the contractor. Households can opt in or out later, and the City passes those changes along.
  2. By November 30, 2026. The City buys 5-gallon food-waste containers and liners and makes them available to The Compost Exchange.
  3. Before January 1, 2027. The Compost Exchange delivers a container and liners to each registered home.
  4. Starting January 1, 2027. Weekly curbside pickup begins. Each time a container is emptied, it comes back with a new liner.
  5. April 1, 2027. The City stops buying liners, and the contractor supplies them from then on, both to new participants and at each weekly pickup.

Under the bid terms, the collected food waste can't go to a landfill. The contract also covers the eight 65-gallon food-waste toters at the Service & Engineering building, which are emptied weekly. It adds an annual curbside pumpkin pickup scheduled between Thanksgiving and December 11.

To see roughly what kinds of food go in a bucket like this, SWACO publishes the list for its Recycling Convenience Center drop-off. It includes produce, grains, pasta and baked goods; coffee grounds and tea, without plastic tea bags; eggs and shells; dairy; meat, bones and seafood; prepared foods; and certain soiled paper and certified compostable products.

The rest of the curb this winter

Most of the routine stays the same. Council voted unanimously on September 21 to keep Local Waste Services, Ltd. for trash, recycling and yard waste over the next five years. The ordinance named its $21.74 per household per month bid the "lowest and best responsible bid." Worthington's current collection day is Friday. For scale, $3.28 for food waste comes to about 15% of the trash contract's per-home rate.

A few smaller changes come up before and alongside the new bucket:

  • Pumpkins and gourds can go in a special bin through December 6 in the parking lot between the Planning & Building and Service & Engineering departments at 380 Highland Avenue. The City asks that they be free of wax, candles, paint, glitter and other decorations, and that they stay out of the green GoZERO compost bins at the Recycling Convenience Center. They're composted at Price Farms in Delaware.
  • Hefty ReNew bags have a deadline. Hefty plans to end the program in June 2027, but Rumpke, which processes the City's recycling, will accept ReNew bags only until February 2027, and Local Waste has confirmed it will collect them until then, according to the City's notice. Households with unused bags after June 2027 can contact Hefty about returns.

Taken together, the new food-waste service is the only one at the curb whose real cost per user depends on how many neighbors use it. At the City's launch estimate of 30%, each participating home costs about $10.93 a month. If every home registers, that falls to $3.28.

This post is general information about a City contract and program, not legal, tax or financial advice. Please confirm the details for your own household with the City of Worthington. If you're weighing how changes like this fit into the costs and upkeep of owning a home in Worthington, the Nick Vlasidis team can walk you through what they mean for your property. Request your VIP home valuation, and we'll put local detail like this alongside your numbers.

Let's Talk About Your Home

Whether you are ready now or still thinking through the possibilities, start with a conversation.